The short answer
Use GIF when you need a looping picture to work absolutely everywhere, such as forums, older email programs, chat apps and upload forms that accept only images. Use MP4 when you need the smallest file and the best colors, and the place you are posting accepts video. Use animated WebP on your own web pages, where it is an image like a GIF but far lighter. Use WebM as a web video alternative to MP4 and APNG when you need lossless full color with smooth transparency.
If you only remember one thing, remember this: GIF is the most compatible and the least efficient. Every other choice trades some compatibility for a smaller and better-looking file.
Side by side
| GIF | MP4 (H.264) | Animated WebP | APNG | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Colors per frame | 256 at most | Millions | Millions | Millions |
| Transparency | On or off only | Not supported | Smooth (8-bit) | Smooth (8-bit) |
| Sound | No | Yes, optional | No | No |
| File size for the same clip | Largest | Smallest, usually by a wide margin | Much smaller than GIF | Often larger than GIF |
| Loops by itself | Yes | Only when the player is set to loop | Yes | Yes |
| Used like | An image | A video | An image | An image |
| Where it works | Everywhere | Almost everywhere | All current browsers, patchy in apps | All current browsers, patchy in apps |
GIF: the universal one
A GIF stores each frame as an indexed picture with up to 256 colors and compresses it without regard to motion. That is why it is large, and why photos and video clips look grainy in it. Its strength is reach. You can put a GIF into nearly anything that accepts a picture, with no player, no codec and no setup, and it will play and loop by itself. The details of how it works are in what is a GIF.
GIF remains the best choice for small, flat graphics (pixel art, logos, simple loops), for anywhere that only accepts image files, and for the catalog-style reactions that people send to one another every day.
MP4: the efficient one
MP4 usually holds video compressed with H.264. Video codecs store changes between frames and predict motion, so they need only a fraction of the data. For a typical clip, the MP4 is several times smaller than the GIF, and it keeps full color, so photos and footage look as they should. The exact ratio depends on the clip; flat cartoons narrow the gap, and camera footage widens it.
The costs are compatibility and behavior. MP4 is a video, so it needs a video player. On a web page you use the video tag, and for it to start by itself the video must be muted, as browsers restrict autoplay with sound. MP4 does not support transparency. And in places that accept only images, such as some forums, you cannot post it as a picture. Many chat apps and social networks accept MP4 and loop short silent clips like GIFs, and they convert your GIFs to MP4 anyway. The converter GIF to MP4 does the same in your browser. If you want a different video format, GIF to Video offers more.
Animated WebP: the modern image
WebP is an image format developed by Google that supports animation, either lossy or lossless, and an 8-bit transparency channel. An animated WebP is used exactly like a GIF, in an ordinary image tag, but it keeps full color and is usually much smaller. All current major browsers display it. The catch is outside the browser: some older apps, email clients, upload forms and image editors do not understand animated WebP, and may show a blank space or a still picture.
Use GIF to WebP to convert a GIF, and WebP to GIF to go back when an app does not accept WebP. If your page may be visited with old software, offer WebP first and keep a GIF as a fallback; the guide on how to use GIFs shows the code.
WebM and APNG
WebM is an open video container, used with the VP8, VP9 or AV1 codecs. It works much like MP4 on the web and is the format Telegram uses for video stickers, which is one reason people convert GIFs with GIF to WebM. Support is good in current browsers, though MP4 remains the safer choice if you only want one video file.
APNG is the animated cousin of PNG. It stores every frame losslessly with smooth transparency and plays in an image tag in current browsers. Lossless frames mean large files, often larger than the GIF, so APNG makes sense for short, sharp animations like icons and interface effects where quality matters more than weight. You can convert with GIF to APNG and APNG to GIF. There are newer animated image formats too, such as AVIF, which is not covered by our tools.
How to choose
Sending in a chat or on social media
Send the GIF unless the app is picky about size. Most apps convert it for you. If the file is too large, shrink it with the compressor, or send MP4, which does the job at a fraction of the size. Our size limit guide lists what common apps accept.
On your own website
Use a muted looping MP4 or WebM for anything longer than a couple of seconds, or for large sizes. Use animated WebP when you want image behavior and your visitors use current browsers. Keep a GIF only as a fallback or for tiny graphics. This choice affects how fast your page loads, which matters to your readers and to search engines.
In email
Use GIF. Email programs differ widely and do not reliably play video or WebP. Keep the file small and make the first frame meaningful, since some programs show only that one.
Presentations and documents
PowerPoint, Keynote and Google Slides play GIFs, and PowerPoint and Keynote also play video clips. For a long or high-quality clip, video is the better choice. For a short loop, a GIF is the simplest.
Stickers and emoji
The app decides. Telegram wants WebM, others take WebP or GIF within strict size rules. The sticker maker prepares files for the common presets.
When you need transparency
For smooth edges, use WebP or APNG. GIF transparency is on or off, so the edge of a cut-out can look jagged on a background it was not made for. MP4 does not carry transparency.
What changes when you convert
- GIF to MP4 or WebM: file size drops, color improves, sound is not added, and you may need to set the video to loop where you use it.
- GIF to WebP or APNG: color improves, transparency becomes smooth if the source had it, and old software may not display it.
- Video to GIF: color and size get worse, sound is lost, and you gain compatibility. Use Video to GIF and keep the clip short.
Converting an existing GIF to a better format cannot recover colors that were lost when the GIF was made. For the best result, convert from the original video when you still have it. Everything in the tools above happens in your browser, so you can try several formats on the same clip and compare the sizes before you pick one.